‘Bausteine zu einer biologischen Weltanschauung’ (1913) Jakob von Uexküll ‘Bedeutungslehre’ (1940) Jakob von Uexküll ‘Biologische Briefe an eine Dame’ (1920b) Jakob von Uexküll ‘Biology and Linguistics’ conference in Tartu in February 1978 ‘Biosemiotics’ book edited by T.A.Sebeok and J.Umiker-Sebeok (1992) is still the largest volume in biosemiotics ‘Biosemiotics’ book edited by T.A.Sebeok and J.Umiker-Sebeok (1992) was probably the first book with ‘biosemiotics’ in the main title ‘Classics of Semiotics’ (Krampen et al. 1987) ‘Streifzhge durch die Umwelten von Tieren und Menschen’ (Uexkhll, Kriszat 1934) ‘Symbol Formation’; Werner 1919 ‘The principle of sympathy’ S.Meyen (1977) ‘Theoretische Biologie’ (1920a, 1928) Jakob von Uexküll ‘Umwelt und Innenwelt der Tiere’ (1909), Jakob von Uexküll ‘Vita aeterna’ periodical ‘Winter Schools on Biosemiotics’ at Moscow University “It from bit” is a way in which information is thought to play a substantive role in the sciences “It from bit” view claims that any causally or dynamically grounded distinction makes a difference, thereby ensuring that it is information (MacKay 1969, see also Bateson 1973) “It from bit” view claims that information is objective and there is nothing else “It from bit” view has originated independently from so many people that it is pointless to attribute an origin, though it probably goes back to Leibniz’ view “It from bit” view is the most liberal and inclusive view “It from bit”, intropic and level intropic substantive views of processes are all found outside of biology “On A New List of Categories” paper (Pierce, 1867) “Semiotic approach in theoretical biology” workshop (1988) 1900s 1910s 1920s 1930s 1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s a bacterium that can swim up a sugar gradient, but tumble if it happens to be swimming down a sugar gradient is an example of far-from-equilibrium processes that deploy different processes depending on differences in the environmental circumstances a bacterium, for example, might swim and continue swimming if it is going up a sugar gradient, but tumble if it finds itself swimming down a sugar gradient (D. T. Campbell, 1990) a blueprint is an external form of representation a broken environment is a non-continuous environment a candle flame cannot deploy different processes depending on differences in the environmental circumstances but if they could search for fuel when the candle was low, that would be an example (Mark H. Bickhard) a candle flame deploys processes that tend to contribute to self-maintenance such as the generation of heat by the flame a candle flame in a standard atmosphere and gravitational field, it induces convection, which pulls in continuing oxygen and removes combustion products (Mark H. Bickhard) a candle flame vaporizes wax into a continuing supply of fuel (Mark H. Bickhard) a candle flame, for example, manifests a short term stability and persistence, but only so long as fuel and oxygen are input to the process (Mark H. Bickhard) a candle flame, in other words, tends to maintain itself; it exhibits self-maintenance (Bickhard, 1993) a candle flame, is an example of far-from-equilibrium processes that tend to maintain themselves becauses it makes several active contributions to its own persistence (Mark H. Bickhard) a candle flame, maintains threshold temperature above combustion (Mark H. Bickhard) a case of Barwise and Seligman information channels a causally efficient organization violates the causal closure of the physical world (Kim) a cautious approach to meaning a chemical bath can be maintained in a far-from-equilibrium condition, for example, with the pumping into the chamber of appropriate chemicals a chemical bath is a far-from-equilibrium process which exhibits at best a minimal autonomy (Mark H. Bickhard) a chemical bath is an example of far-from-equilibrium processes dependent for their continued existence on continued external sources of support a chemical bath is dependent on the external pumps continuing to pump the necessary solutions into the bath, and on the external reservoirs of those solutions continuing to contain sufficient quantities of those solutions (Mark H. Bickhard) a child's toy block a circle and a rectangle are differing visual aspects of one underlying cylinder "a classic paradigm of abbreviatory definition is ""bachelor = unmarried male""" a code implies a semantics (Barbieri (2001)) a component is a type a consequence of earlier system interactions with the environment is a vicariant a consequence of the interactive model of representation per se is an inherent integration of issues of representation, action, and motivation a context provides a natural framework a direct example of construing what the interactive model would take as a differentiation as being more than that, as being a representation of that which has been differentiated (Mark H. Bickhard) a direct triggering indication of the relevant interaction is a causing of that interaction a dynamic alternative model of function is offered in which function emergences in particular special kinds of far-from-equilibrium open systems a dynamic version of implicit definition a dynamic version of implicit definition would be the class of environments that would permit a process interacting with one of those environments to reach completion: the process implicitly defines its class of favorable environments a dysfunctional kidney does not filter blood, then this particular kidney has the function of filtering blood, but it does not do so A far-from-equilibrium system that is recursively self-maintenant can differentiate environmental conditions that serve to indicate the appropriateness of particular further interactions for maintaining far-from-equilibrium conditions (Mark H. Bickhard) a feature of a single self-reproducing system (SRS) a feature of the whole population of self-reproducing systems (SRSs) a few more a frog that sees a fly and simultaneously sees the shadow of a hawk will most likely choose to jump in the water rather than flick its tongue and try to eat the fly a full explanation of why internal state is recruited as a cause of behavior - of why indicates the success of - involves the fact that C carries information about (indicates) F which is the set of conditions on which the success of M depends a fundamental issue in physics, biology, and cognitive science is where to draw the necessary epistemic cut between the coherent physical dynamics and its rate-independent semiotic description (Pattee) a genetic code has an immediate advantage for even nonsexual organisms a genetic code is opening up the possibility of later major transitions a good example a heart, for example, may serve a function for a parasite, but be dysfunctional for the host a history will be repeated a kidney exist because their evolutionary predecessors did in fact filter blood a kidney has that function even if it is not serving it a kidney, then, may have the function of, say, filtering blood, even if this particular kidney doesn't in fact filter blood (Mark H. Bickhard) a less powerful manner of differentiation of environments a lion in the zoo a longer time scale process of replacement and recreation is a longer time scale dedicated metabolism a model of representational content is in every case a specification that is available at best to an observer analyzing the organism, not to the organism itself (Mark H. Bickhard) a model of the emergence of representation as a special kind of function is delineated a model of the emergence of representation is an interactive model of representation a modern unification of biology has to be based on the fundamentally semiotic nature of life (Hoffmeyer) a more detailed elaboration of the model a neurotransmitter docks in a receptor molecule on the surface of a cell a neurotransmitter triggers resulting biochemical activity inside the cell a neurotransmitter triggers the internal cell activity a number of approaches to modeling function a number of approaches to modeling representation a part of a system serves a function with respect to the whole system insofar as it contributes to the maintenance of the system's far from equilibrium conditions (Bickhard, 1993; Christensen, Collier, Hooker a part of the environment a part of the system must filter blood a part or aspect of a system will have a function insofar as it is an instance of a type which tends to serve, has a disposition to serve, that function for the type of the overall system (Mark H. Bickhard) a particle metaphysics a particle metaphysics is not a legitimate, even necessary, locus of causal power (Mark H. Bickhard) a particle metaphysics makes the possibility of causal emergence of process organization, seriously problematic a passive differentiation is a differentiation nevertheless, and can serve as the basis for further indications of interactive potentiality a passive system is a system with no outputs a physical information system requires some degree of discreteness a pointer to a subroutine can indicate the potentiality of the interactions that would be engaged in by that subroutine a poison docks in a receptor molecule on the surface of a cell a poison triggers the internal cell activity a population as a set of elementary self-reproducing system (SRS) is not an integrated entity which has epiphenomena belonging to it as a system a population as an integral whole is a self-reproducing system (SRS), whereas a population of non-interacting individuals is not (Kalevi Kull) a predication about the environment should be undertaken in the presence of some sufficient subset of that set of supporting properties (Mark H. Bickhard) a principal and distinctive characteristic of semiotic biology lays in the understanding that in living, entities do not interact like mechanical bodies (Kull 1999: 386) a principal and distinctive characteristic of semiotic biology lays in the understanding that in living, entities interact like messages, the pieces of text (Kull 1999: 386) a process in a recursively self-maintenant system dynamically presupposes whatever those conditions are, internal to the system or external to the system, that support its being functional for the system a process metaphysics consistent with contemporary quantum field theory is examined, it supports notions of emergence rather than defeating them a process metaphysics opens up the possibility of emergent causal power, non-epiphenomenal emergence, in new process organizations a process metaphysics precludes the denial of potential causal power and emergent causal power to organization a process metaphysics, on the other hand, makes organization intrinsic to all reality, at all levels a process model of the emergence of representation a process that is far from thermodynamic equilibrium will move toward equilibrium, and thus cease to exist, unless some active counterinfluence is operative a process will succeed or fail in serving its function(s) in a self maintenant far from equilibrium system depending, in part, on whether or not its dynamic presuppositions hold (Mark H. Bickhard) a programmatic task a protein code would allow a finite number of proteins to map an open-ended range of possible products (Collier) a recursive self-maintenant system can shift among differing kinds of processes in order to maintain the property of being self-maintenant in varying conditions (Mark H. Bickhard) a recursive self-maintenant system must have some way of differentiating those environments in which it will engage in one process versus those in which it will engage in some other process (Mark H. Bickhard) a recursively self-maintenant system can adopt varying ways of being self-maintenant in appropriate response to environmental changes a recursively self-maintenant system is one that can contribute to the maintenance of its condition of being self-maintenant (Bickhard, 1993; see also Christensen, Collier, Hooker) a recursively self-maintenant system may just switch from one interaction with its environment to another as differentiated conditions change a recursively self-maintenant system may set up indications of multiple interactions that would be appropriate in current circumstances, and engage in some more complicated process of action selection or interaction selection a representation is an internal state that has been recruited via instrumental conditioning to participate in the cause of some behavior (Dretske) "a representation represents falsely if that content is false of a current representational target so, if a content of ""cow"" is attributed to a horse as target, that will be false (Millikan, 1984, 1993; Cummins, 1996)" a representation represents whatever it is its proper function to represent a requirement for information to be discriminating is that its embodiment is complex a restricted notion of the physical is having to do with only efficient causation a rock is an example of energy well process organizations a selected trait will contain information produced by certain genes that are selected along with the trait (Wright 1973, Millikan 1989, Neander 1991) a self maintenant system can maintain itself over some range of conditions — if a candle is put into a vacuum or doused with water, it ceases a self-maintenant system contributes to its own conditions of stability and persistence (Mark H. Bickhard) a self-reproducing system (SRS) represents a destabilizing force in a system where it exists a series of dynamic interpretants will get somebody closer and closer to the final interpretant a set of different particular semiosis (recognitions, adaptations) forms a language, if the same type of interaction could result distinctively different behaviour i.e a sign does not signify in all respects and has some particular signifying element (Peirce) a sign may determine a mind to a conduct a similar concept a simple process for such selection would be to select among the indicated potentialities that interaction whose outcomes best satisfy, or best further, current system goals (Mark H. Bickhard) a special kind of function is that of indicating future potentialities for interactions and their expectable internal consequences a specific example a statue is an external form of representation a statue must be understood as a statue a straightforward counterexample to a model a straightforward counterexample to the asymmetric dependency criterion a subweb of indicated interactive potentiality might even exhibit the property of closure: all states in the web are reachable from all other states via some class of interactions that relate those states a switching mechanism is an infrastructure in the system that engages in the relevant shifts of system processes a system could be more or less rational; rationality is something that can occur at levels other than that of the human psyche (Kalevi Kull) a system which generates and tests hypotheses about its environment a system which generates and tests hypotheses about its environment has a set of hypotheses which are present in coded, symbolic form in order to satisfy the intuition about the nature of hypotheses a system which generates and tests hypotheses about its environment must be subject to variation and test in relation to an external world a system which generates and tests hypotheses about its environment must have some principle of correspondence whereby good hypotheses about this world can be retained and stored while bad ones are discarded a system which generates hypotheses about its environment a system which tests hypotheses about its environment a test is a differentiating process a test is performed and, under some conditions, control is transferred out of the subsystem while under other conditions control will be transferred to some interactive subsystem, perhaps complex a TOTE structure is a Test-Operate-Test-Exit structure a trait is functional if it is selected for, meaning that it is an adaptation (Wright 1973, Millikan 1989, Neander 1991) a type can be a filter that sorts out tokens of a particular kind a variation on Shannon methods a view of representation a whole system serves a function with respect to the whole system insofar as it contributes to the maintenance of the system's far from equilibrium conditions (Bickhard, 1993; Christensen, Collier, Hooker) A. Bramwell A. Heschl A. Heschl showed the equality of cognitive and adaptive processes A. Levich A. Turovski abbreviatory definition abbreviatory definition is an explicit definition of new terms in a logic using terms already available in that logic abbreviatory definition, however, is not the only legitimate form of definition abductive reasoning ability to anticipate what interactions might be possible next ability to carry small variations in the lower level ability to discriminate ability to mutate abiotic conditions abiotic conditions do not usually form regular rows of valleys, and consequently, geo-species cannot represent regular sets of species able to filter blood aboutness and truth value are the semantics for emergent representation aboutness is a basic normative issue of representation absence of any meaning, in a stretch of the human genome absolutely determinate abstract aspect to infomorphisms abstract representation accept a terminology accept an approach accept symbiogenetic theory of origin of eucaryotes accept the consequences acceptable models of emergence acceptance of the semiotic view by biologists accepted theoretical biology accepting symbiogenetic theory of origin of eucaryotes, we can conclude that eucaryotic organisms have usually federative species access cannot be simply presupposed in a model of representation access is a primitive function built into a machine, but it is not primitive in the relationships between machine and the world accidental regularities accidental regularities do not carry information (Barwise and Seligman) accidental regularities do not count for the transmission of information accomplished biologists accomplishment of relevant work according to a sectarian view according to a sectarian view of Meyer-Abich, physics should be a part of biology, not vice versa according to an etiological approach of normative functions according to Darwinism according to our understanding of the theoretical system of biology according to Ransdell according to the approach used in a review according to the best science of today according to the biosemiotic view according to the etiological account according to the interactive model of representation according to the meaning given to a notion account for abstractions such as numbers account for all aspects of phenotypic traits account for higher order accomplishments or possibilities requires, among other things, addressing the representation of abstractions account for input processing account for objects in terms of atoms and molecules is a higher order accomplishment account for objects in terms of earth, air, fire, and water is a higher order accomplishment account for objects in terms of theories about objects is a higher order accomplishment account for representations of physical objects account for representations such as of objects account for the inner representations account for the possibility of error account for the very possibility of error-guided behavior account for the very possibility of error-guided learning account of function in biology by Maturana and Varela account of function in biology that breaks the symmetries of genes account of how indicated potential interactions could be selected account of how representation makes a difference in the processes of the world account of information flow in distributed systems by Barwise and Seligman (1997) account of system goals account of the possibility of system detectable error accounting for that emergence is among the central problems of naturalism accounting for the possibility of erro accounting for the possibility of system detectable error; achieve a wide distribution in biologists’ writings achieve specific goals achieve the acceptance of the semiotic view by biologists acknowledge the importance of sexual selection acknowledge the importance of something acquired characters across the course of somebody’s intellectual life action activation action and motivation emerge naturally and necessarily as aspects of one single underlying ontology of the interactive agent (Bickhard) action and representation are not, and cannot be, distinct modules action based model action based perception action based representation action cannot be a logical interpretant (Pierce 1906) action evaluation action feedback action framework action framework for understanding representation action is a fragmentation of mentality action is a functional module action is taken to be dependent on encodings action is taken to be interpreting encodings action of signs action selection action selection in a recursively self-maintenant system can occur via more complex selection processes among indicated interaction potentialities action selection in a recursively self-maintenant system can occur via simple triggering action stimulation action systems are interactively competent control structures actions to be performed activation vector active constructive processes active contributions of far-from-equilibrium systems to their own stability active counterinfluence actual reason for the origin of regular species actual representation actuators are input/output systems ad hoc explanations ad hoc ontologies ad hoc postulates adaptation by natural selection is a semiotic fine-tuning (Salthe) adaptation is a semiotic phenomenon adaptation is a semiotic phenomenon, that is, a process of signification (E. Baer 1984: 6) adaptive characters of organisms adaptive far-from-equilibrium autonomy adaptive landscape of abiotic conditions adaptive space add a layer of modality additional features integrating population into one whole additional hurdle to the making of an analysis additional interpretants additional modules of cognition additional properties address a challenge address briefly address logical challenges address metaphysical challenges address the issue of coding address the representation of abstractions address this issue address vexing issues addressee adds further restrictions adequacy of pointers adequacy of subroutines adequacy of the interactive model for all forms of purported representation adhere to a philosophy Adolf Meyer-Abich (1893–1971) adopt a restricted notion of the physical advantages of a a physical information system adversion to an observer adversion to evolution adversion to evolution does not help because the problem is a logical one and applies to evolution just as much as to learning and development (Bickhard, 1991, 1993; Fodor, 1981) adversion to explanation adversion to explanation as constituting the ontology of representation afford multiple potentialities of manipulations afford multiple potentialities of visual scans after the transition of evolution aim of a book chapter aim of a sign chain algorithmic approaches used for information measurement algorithmic information theory is useful for ecological networks algorithmic information theory is useful for interspecies communication algorithmic information theory is useful for intraspecies communication algorithmic methods used for information measurement algorithmic methods used for information measurement are more appropriate for dealing with information in biological organism algorithmic methods used for information measurement work best on individuals algorithmic technologies used for information measurement all acceptable premises express only facts, and, therefore, do not contain any normative terms all acceptable premises of an argument all genuine causal powers reside in the lowest level of particle interactions all genuine pragmatist approaches share a rejection of correspondence models of representation all indications of possible system interactions are conditional at least in the sense that they are evoked in certain internal system conditions, and not in others all indications of possible system interactions are conditional on particular internal states of the system all living beings are in some extent adapted, because they have undergone differential reproduction during their previous evolution all living systems all of causality is resident at the level of the most fundamental particles (Kim 1993, 1997, 1998) all of Peirce's work in philosophy all of the main aspects are highly controversial all organizations are ultimately quantum field organizations (Mike Bickhard) all scales of organization of process are candidates for the non-epiphenomenal emergence of new causally efficacious power (Mark H. Bickhard) all thought is in signs (Peirce) allow for the combination of language structure with tolerance structure allow gradual increases in the size of information space almost any almost exclusively almost unnoticed results along the lines of a time period alternative account of normative function alternative accounts of function in biology alternative accounts of function in biology focus on organizational role (Maturana and Varela 1980, Rosen 1991, Cummins 1983) alternative approaches to the interactive model of representational content alternative channels of heredity alternative channels of inheritance alternative model of representation alternative models of representation alternative modes of heredity are ultimately grounded in the genes (Maynard Smith’s (2000b)) alternative self-maintaining processes always fail always ultimately fail ambiguity in the regularities underlying the information channels involved in gene expression amenable to generalization amenable to mathematical exploration among the theories amount of information capacity of a channel an action framework for understanding representation forces a variation and selection constructivism, an evolutionary epistemology (D. T. Campbell, 1974) an alternative perspective an assumption is strongly motivated an empiricist assumption an etiological approach in fact fails to provide a naturalistic account of normative function (Mark H. Bickhard) an example might be primitive cells that, say, metabolize sulfur and have appropriate infrastructure for doing so, but which have no alternatives available, and thus no need to switch among alternatives (Mark H. Bickhard) an example of a recursively self-maintenant system is a bacterium, for a real example, can swim up a sugar gradient, but tumble if it finds itself swimming down a sugar gradient (Campbell, D. T. 1974a, 1974b, 1990) an example of causal correspondence is that created by light bouncing off an object and into the eye of an observer "an example of conventional correspondence is that the word ""fire"" carries information about the phenomenon of fire " an example of intervening interactions is turning the object around to create the possibility of the visual scan from that angle an example of lawful correspondence is the lawfulness of a light propagation from an object an example of strictly informational correspondence is the smoke that carries information about fire an indicated outcome of an indicated process might not obtain -- the process might not reach completion -- even if the process is engaged in an indicated process might not in fact contribute to self maintenance an indication of the appropriateness of an interaction in a recursively self-maintenant system, dynamically presupposes that those conditions obtain an infinity of further signs both proceed and precede from any given sign (Peirce) an interaction (or behavior) (M), might indicate still further interactions (or behaviors) (Ms) an interaction (or behavior) (M), that is indicated, might itself, if undertaken, detect or create still further environmental conditions (Fs) (Mark H. Bickhard) an interaction might create an environmental condition (F) an interaction might detect an environmental condition (F) that that organism could not detect with passive input processing an interactive representation in a recursively self-maintenant system may be fallibly discovered to be false an interactive representation in a recursively self-maintenant system may be false: the dynamically presupposed conditions may not be true "an internal state in a system is recruited as a ""cause"" of a behavior because it indicates the success of that behavior (Mark H. Bickhard) " an observer could infer from the fact that the system has arrived at A that the system is in an environment with such and such properties -- if the observer knew what properties did in fact underlie arriving at internal state A an organism cannot have access to its own representational contents (Mark H. Bickhard) an organized process is a legitimate, even necessary, locus of causal power an unsound argument is based on a false premise analogous understanding analogy between scientific principles analogy of language analogy of representations analysis of biological form analysis of biological teleology analysis of the application of the tools and notions of semiotics (text, translation, interpretation, semiosis, types of sign, meaning) in the biological realm (Kull 1999: 386) analysis of the conditions required for something analyze a scientific concept analyze biological channels analyze the concept of adaptation from the point of view of subjective biology And perhaps X and Y each serve as the conditions for still further indications of potentiality, and so on (Mark H. Bickhard) animal communication studies animal semiosis is called zoosemiotics another aspect of the dynamical decoupling of energy and information in biological systems another one-level self-reproducing system (SRS) another useful tool answer questions within a purely mechanist and physicalist framework anthroposemiosis anti-Cartesian project anticipations are indications of possible interactions anticipations detectable by the system anticipations have truth values for the system anticipations of possible interactions anticipations of possible interactions constitute the model of interactive representation anticipations of possible interactions would permit the agent to select among those possibilities that are most suited to its current internal conditions anticipations of possible interactions would permit the agent to select those possibilities that are most to be avoided anticipatory aspect of interactive systems anticipatory indications of potentiality involve dynamic presuppositions anti-Darwinian theories any approach or programme that permits cognition to seem autonomous is foundationally flawed any change of hereditary structure any components or parts of a system serve such a function insofar as they make such a contribution (Mark H. Bickhard) any difference between organisms may potentially reduce the competition between them any indicated interaction anywhere in the subweb is reachable as a direct interaction potentiality via various intermediary conditional interactions any instance of signification contains a sign-vehicle, an object and interpretant (Peirce) any model of a real agent with a real mind any model which cannot account for system-detectable error is impeached any new organization of process will instantiate new properties, and some of them may be interesting, non-linear, and capable of downward causation -- some of them may be interestingly emergent any one of these interactions potentialities is available or reachable from any other so, the subweb of interactive potentialities are internally reachable any particular possible outcome of an interaction any particular possible outcome of an interaction serves to differentiate those environments what would yield that outcome from those that would yield a different outcome: the outcomes differentiate types of environments any possible outcome of an interaction any sign is itself the interpretant of some further sign (Peirce) any sign may display some combination of iconic, indexical and symbolic characteristics (Peirce) any sign must determine an interpretant in order to count as a sign, and interpretants are themselves signs, infinite chains of signs seem to become conceptually necessary (Peirce) any sign must generate an interpretant in order to be a sign (Peirce) any sign or representation will have a sign-vehicle, an object, and an interpretant (Pierce) any sign whose sign-vehicle relies on simple abstracted qualities is called a qualisign any sign whose sign-vehicle relies upon conventions, habits or laws is called legisigns any sign whose sign-vehicle relies upon existential connections with its object is called a sinsign any stability of a chemical bath is dependent on the continuing operation of the pumps and availability of the chemicals anything that has causal power, will have causal power as an organized feature of the world (Mark H. Bickhard) aporia in a model appear at the origin of life appear effects of heterochrony appear open criticism of the whole approach appearances to the contrary, at least in two important instances, derive from incorrect metaphysics, false epistemologies, and illegitimate logical restrictions applicability of Zipf’s law in the ecological communities applicable information concepts application for funding application of information theoretic methods to biology application of information theory application of information theory in biology application of N. Wiener’s feedback loop in neurobiology application of Uexküll’s functional circle in neurobiology applied mathematics in every field of biology apply a distinction apply a proposed interpretation of semiosis apply an epistemology t othe research apply an interpretation apply Dawkins' metaphor apply Saussurean approach to molecular processes of the cell apply semiotic analysis to the biological systems apply semiotic approach in biology apply something more broadly apply the natural language as a way to describe the systems apply the notion of information to the internal perspective of autopoietic systems apply the notion of information to the internal perspective of autopoietic systems, using the convenient connection from systems theory between the concept of operationality and the concept of information apply the notion of plan to the explanation of animal behaviour apply the notions used by the biologists of vitalistic paradigm in the contemporary biology by means of semiotic terminology (Kalevi Kull) apply to nonsexual bacteria apply to other aspects of approach to all representation approach to modeling representation approach to understanding function Approache to modeling function Approaches to modeling representation appropriate indications of potentiality constitute representational content appropriate indications of potentiality for any particular environment appropriate interactions appropriate interactions for an environment appropriate interactions for an environment tend to be self-maintaining appropriate interactive potentialities appropriate response to environmental changes appropriate system organizations appropriateness of an interaction in a recursively self-maintenant system is a normative notion, and the normativity is a functional normativity appropriateness of particular interactions architectural frameworks for modeling anticipations of possible interactions are higher level regularities simply the working out of the particle interactions with the relevant initial and boundary conditions? are no doubt important are the properties and regularities of the organization the stage upon which and within which the particles work out their interactions? argument against system detectable error argument based on a particle metaphysics arguments about causally epiphenomenal emergence arise of discreteness Aristotle’s form principle Aristotle’s form principle held to be the beginning of vitalism Aristotle's model of perception arrive at a designated outcome arrive at a full understanding of an object arrive at a state arrive at internal differentiating states artifactual biological information channels artificial intelligence and cognitive science are dominated by programmatic assumptions that make their own highest level programmatic aspirations impossible (Bickhard & Terveen, 1995) as a chain of signs moves towards a final end there are different interpretants playing different but significant roles as an integral whole as far as as is often the case in biology as previously mentioned ascribe the greatest importance to an aspect ask a variety of questions aspect of a methodology aspect of a system aspect of human sciences aspect of interpretation aspect of molecular biology aspect of the control infrastructure of a system aspects discussed in biosemiotics aspects of actuality aspects of an ontology of interactive system organization aspects of epistemic relationship aspects of genetic information aspects of modality aspects of necessity aspects of phenotypic traits aspects of possibility aspects of quantum fields aspects of the information transmitted aspects of the same process aspirations of understanding mental processes assignment of types of system assimilate an object into the system of signs associate interactions with indications of expectable internal interaction outcomes associate signs with cognition associated internal outcomes association of information with heredity associations of the semiotic view in biology assume an encodingism toward representation assume that all representations are encodings assume that all representations are stand-ins assume the possible application of linguistics in biology assumption of a general value assumption of small variations assure something to be correct astronomy as a study of semiotic asymmetric dependence asymmetry between equilibrium processes and far-from-equilibrium processes asymmetry between function and dysfunction at an explicit level at an implicit level at an implicit level the content of an indication will be particular properties, or combinations of properties at any particular point in the sign chain the dynamic interpretant represents an incomplete understanding, or interpretation, of the dynamic object at any rate at first seem at least in name at least not explicitly at least potentially at least two things at least two things are recognized by a biosystem as different things at the expense of efficiency at the psychological level at the start of a paragraph at the very least at various points atom is a stable organization of processes atom is a straightforward example of energy well process stability because if sufficient energy is introduced into this process, it is altered and perhaps disintegrates; it loses its cohesion (Mark H. Bickhard) atoms are a furious process of electron waves around an even more furious dance of quarks and gluons atoms are straightforward examples of energy well process stability atoms, molecules, and much of the standard furniture of the world is temporally persisting because of such energy well stabilities attack the theory of selection attempt to avoid encodingist presuppositions attempt to locate errors attempt to render implicit content in explicit form attempt to use a semiotic approach to solve the problem of coexistence of self-reproducing systems (SRSs) attempts to handle the problem of representational error attempts to treat enzyme action biosemiotically attendant problems attractive idea attribute causal power to organization attribute causal power to quantum fields attribute information to biological systems in a non-instrumental way attributes of life attribution of information to a system August Weismann authoritative substantive uses of information in biology authoritative usages authoritative views autogenetic theories autogenetic theory of evolution (C.Nägeli, T.Eimer) autogenetic theory of evolution states that the existence of an immanent (intrinsic) source of evolutionary change, the intrinsic trend towards the diversification of structure and behaviour autonomous agents approaches Autonomy autonomy in this sense is a graded concept: there are differing kinds and degrees of such active contributions (Mark H. Bickhard) autonomy is a property of systems in the sense of actively contributing to their own persistence Autonomy is modeled in terms of the property of certain far-from-equilibrium open systems to contribute toward maintaining themselves in their far-from-equilibrium conditions Autonomy, Function, and Representation autopoietic structures autopoietic systems avoid errors avoid programmatic errors avoid the complexities avoid the information technology avoid the problems avoid the problems of encodingism avoidance of mathematics avoidance of ontological concerns yields a non-naturalistic outcome awkward word B. Goodwin B. van Heusden B. van Heusden has tried to formulate the specificity of human perception bacteria that generate hypotheses about their environment bacteria that test hypotheses about their environment bad hypotheses about the environment of a system Baer and not Darwin would become the central historical figure in theoretical biology (Salthe) Baer’s interpretation of biological time Baerian biology Baerian biology has been in a suppressed minority position almost throughout of this century, except may be only for the first and last decades i.e., in the periods of neovitalism or organicism, and post-Darwinism Baldwin’s effect Barbieri’s requirements for a code Barwise and Seligman approach Barwise and Seligman approach invokes regularities, which cannot be understood purely formally but even this informal part of their approach does not imply anything more than non-accidental relations, which can be found in the most basic physics based on a metaphysical view basic dilemmas of biology basic framework basic intuition basic manner in which something occurs basic ontology of the universe basic particles basic representational nature basic sign structure basic speciation process be a matter of degree be a matter of gloss be a representation of that which has been differentiated be able to compare our representations with what they purport to represent be able to detect error in our own representations be able to determine what your own representations are supposed to represent be able to filter blood be able to persist at all be able to persist under certain conditions be addressed in a more general way be addressed in greater detail be adequate for the emergence of function be an adversion to an observer be analyzed as communication channels be applied to biology be assured be at stake be backward looking be backward looking down the stream of inputs coming into the organism be championed by be characterized in the same way be clarified below be clear be committed to substantive information accounts be compared to the current target be constructed via processing of inputs be controversially championed by be crucial to a work be crucial to the possibility of error of representation be deeply interested in the theory of any particular biological phenomenon be defined using only terms already present in the premises of the argument be dependent on external processes be designed by humans be difficult to find be discussed be eliminated if it fails be embedded in the literature be familiar with a concept in day-to-day encounters be far from semiotics be favourable to reproduction be favoured probabilistically be founded on a logical incoherence be future looking be geographically isolated be grounded in chemistry be grounded in physics be hidden from view in macroscopic interactions be important in each case be impossible be in a differentiating state be in close communication with be informed by the cognitive contents be inherently integrated be intellectually isolated be invariant under all possible interactions be invoked via processing of inputs be involved in making something possible be modeled in a specific way be non-natural in the sense of being true but superfluous be not open to the system to determine its own representational content be not so deeply interested in the theory of any particular biological phenomenon be of undeniable importance be open to information be open to the system to determine its own representational content be open to the system to determine what its own representations are supposed to represent be overlooked be placed into a hierarchy be placed into a nested hierarchy be placed into an increasingly nested hierarchy be present in the premises of the argument be progressively differentiated in development over the course of some years be recruited via instrumental conditioning be reduced to genetic information be reducible be subject to be eliminated if it fails be subject to be tried out be the basis for biology be thought to play a substantive role in the sciences be tried out be useful to be usually taken as be willing to accept the consequences be worth noting that bear fruit bear in mind the analogies between scientific notions because it seems to become a paradigm for the theory of General Biology become a signifier become generally accepted become the dominating view in a science become the dominating view in biology become unpopular become very popular Bedeutungslehre by J.von Uexküll is one of the first books on biosemiotics before the transition of evolution beginning of biophysics beginning of genetics through the rediscovery of Mendel’s laws; beginning of mathematical biology beginning of research into population variability, under the name of biometry (K.Pearson) beginning of the century beginnings of biosemiotics should be traced back, however, to its roots in the work of the Estonian born German biologist Jakob von Uexküll (1864-1944) (Jesper Hoffmeyer) behavior control networks composed of proteins and other substances behavioral transmission between organisms behaviour, involving the cognitive processes, can in fact be viewed as the continuous formulation, testing, and improvement of hypotheses according to criteria of behavioural success, whatever this may be (A. Heschl) Belew belief in a teleological force in nature belief in teleology beliefs anchored in the thinking of scientists benefit the organism Berlinski Bertrand Russell’s book ‘The Analysis of Mind’ beside the point best contemporary science Beth's theorem Beth's theorem applies to the implicit definition of single terms Beth's theorem holds only for first order predicate logic and infinite models Beth's theorem is commonly cited as a reason to ignore implicit definition (Doyle, 1985) Beth's theorem, states that implicit and explicit definition are of equal power (Chang & Keisler, 1990) better understanding of deep but forgotten investigations between the meaningful areas there is an unrecogizable area between the meaningful areas there is hiatus between the neurotransmitter and the cell activities there is nomological informational correspondence between the poison and the cell activities there is nomological informational correspondence beyond Dretske's model beyond the ken of Dretske's model bibliography binary discriminations Biochemist biochemistry is based on the binomial or dyadic cause-effect model biocybernetic notions Biocybernetics biogenesis is a biological problem biologic semioticians Biological Abstracts CD biological agents biological autonomy biological background of language origins biological channels biological communication studies biological congresses biological environment biological foundations of language biological ground for representation biological information channels biological information channels are complex themselves biological information channels are interconnected in complex ways that show considerable logical depth indicating organization (Bennett 1985) biological information channels are nothing if not distributed biological information channels carry complex information biological information channels is a technique for studying biological information biological information channels typically show organized complexity (Collier and Hooker 1999) biological information involves something more than substantive information (Collier) biological information transmission biological memory biological phenomena acceptable to scientists of other philosophical backgrounds biological pragmatics biological processes cannot be reduced to energy governed ones because of differences in organized complexity biological processes that support functionality biological recognition and biological adaptation represent the simpliest forms of semiosis (Kalevi Kull) biological reviews biological roots of cognition biological species Biological Station of Naples biological studies biological systems are both complicated and complexly organized biologists influenced by neovitalistic approaches biologists of clearly neovitalistic inclination biologists of neovitalistic trend biologists of vitalistic paradigm biologists still cannot precisely define or delimit what to call the living process (Kalevi Kull) biology and linguistics Biology and linguistics conference biology becomes one thread in society’s entanglements with the world, rather than a compartment of sure knowledge biology can make some real contribution towards answering “what is language essentially?” biosemiosis is the sign action in living systems biosemiotic conception suggests that the life sphere is permeated by sign processes (semiosis) and signification (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotic course at Tallinn University of Educational Sciences biosemiotic courses biosemiotic meetings biosemiotic sections in conferences biosemiotic views biosemiotics and biotechnology biosemiotics appear to be involved in hermeneutics all and this trend is called biohermeneutics (Chebanov) biosemiotics as a term did not appear in international literature until introduced by the American linguist and semiotician Thomas A. Sebeok in 1986 (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics as a term, was used in Russian semiotic literature by Yuri Stepanov as early as 1971 (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics attempt to pave a way of conjoining culture with nature, through the proper understanding of the relationships between ‘external and internal nature’ (Hoffmeyer 1993: 155) biosemiotics attempt to pave a way of conjoining humanities with natural sciences, through the proper understanding of the relationships between ‘external and internal nature (Hoffmeyer 1993) biosemiotics attempt to research the origins of semiotic phenomena biosemiotics attempt to understand the relationships between external and internal nature biosemiotics attempts to use semiotic concepts to answer questions about the biologic and evolutionary emergence of meaning, intentionality and a psychic world biosemiotics belongs in large part to nature, in some part to culture, which is, of course, also a part of nature (Sebeok) biosemiotics builds a new foundation for biology biosemiotics can be defined as the science of signs in living systems biosemiotics can be defined as the science of signs in living systems (Kalevi Kull) biosemiotics can be regarded as a branch of the life science (Sebeok) biosemiotics can be regarded as belonging in large part to nature, in some part to culture, which is, of course, also a part of nature (Sebeok 1991: 22) biosemiotics can be seen as a contribution to a general theory of evolution, involving a synthesis of different disciplines (Emmeche) biosemiotics can be seen as a contribution to a general theory of evolution, involving a synthesis of different disciplines (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics can be seen not only as a branch of semiotics, but also as an approach in theoretical biology (Kalevi Kull) biosemiotics can be viewed as a root of both biology and semiotics rather than a branch of semiotics (Sharov 1998: 404-405) biosemiotics claims that cause-effect model is not sufficient if biochemical and physiological processes are organised in obedience to their semiotic function in the integrated organism biosemiotics claims that life-processes are part of and are organised in obedience to a semiotic dynamic (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics deals with sign processes in nature in all dimensions biosemiotics deals with the emergence of semiosis in nature, which may coincide with or anticipate the emergence of living cells (Emmeche) biosemiotics deals with the emergence of semiosis in nature, which may coincide with or anticipate the emergence of living cells (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics deals with the horizontal aspects of semiosis in inner sign functions in the immune and nervous systems (Emmeche) biosemiotics deals with the horizontal aspects of semiosis in plant and animal communication (Emmeche) biosemiotics deals with the horizontal aspects of semiosis in plant and animal communication (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics deals with the horizontal aspects of semiosis in sign functions in the immune and nervous systems (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics deals with the horizontal aspects of semiosis in the ontogeny of organisms (Emmeche) biosemiotics deals with the horizontal aspects of semiosis in the ontogeny of organisms (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics deals with the horizontal aspects of semiosis in the semiotics of cognition and language (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics deals with the natural history of signs (Emmeche) biosemiotics deals with the natural history of signs (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics deals with the semiotics of cognition and language (Emmeche) biosemiotics describes the continuity between matter and mind biosemiotics does not imply any denial of the anchoring of life-processes in well-established physical and chemical lawfulness (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics draws upon the insights of fields like systems theory, theoretical biology and the physics of complex self-organized systems biosemiotics enables the introduction of subjectness, i.e. organism as a subject, into the biological realm (cf Uexküll 1931b, Woltereck 1932) biosemiotics has still not found its place in biology (Kalevi Kull) biosemiotics has to be based on the fundamentally semiotic nature of life (Hoffmeyer 1997) biosemiotics has under its umbrella a diversity of interests and viewpoints (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics helps to understand the development of mental features through the semiotically interpreted evolutionary epistemology (Schult 1989, Hoffmeyer 1996b) Biosemiotics in the twentieth century : a view from biology (Kalevi Kull)  biosemiotics integrates findings related to sign actions in living systems, from various scientific fields biosemiotics is a branch of general semiotics, but the existence of signs in its subject matter is not necessarily presupposed (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is a branch of general semiotics, but the existence of signs in its subject matter is not necessarily presupposed, insofar as the origin of semiosis in the universe is one of the riddles to be solved (Emmeche 1992: 78) biosemiotics is a modern unification of biology (Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is a new paradigm for biology or theoretical biology (Anderson et al. 1984; Hoffmeyer & Emmeche 1991; Eder, Rembold 1992; Kull 1993a; cf Anderson 1990) biosemiotics is an attempt to apply semiotics to biological systems in order to account for communication from the molecular level through the behavioral and social biosemiotics is an inevitable frontier that semiotic theory cannot for long delay exploring (J. Deely) biosemiotics is concerned with the interpretation of nature's sign universe in the context of the semiotic tradition from Charles Sanders Peirce (1839-1914) biosemiotics is concerned with the sign-aspects of the processes of life itself (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is divided in endosemiotics and exosemiotics (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is divided in horizontal semiotics and vertical semiotics biosemiotics is not concerned with the sign-character of the theoretical structure of life-sciences) (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is not one among other biological subdisciplines but rather constitutes a certain theoretical frame for the study of biology (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is not yet a specific disciplinary research programme, but a general perspective on life biosemiotics is semiotic biology (Kalevi Kull) biosemiotics is still in the phase of 'vagueness' (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is the biology that interprets living systems as sign systems (Emmeche, Kull, Stjernfelt 2002: 26) biosemiotics is the scientific study of biosemiosis (Emmeche, Kull, Stjernfelt 2002: 9) biosemiotics is the study of living systems from a semiotic perspective (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics is the study of signs, of communication, and of information in living organisms (Oxford Dictionary of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, 1997) biosemiotics is the study of the processes of communication and signification (Sebeok) biosemiotics is the study of the twin processes of communication and signification (Sebeok) biosemiotics may also help people to understand higher forms of mind and the variety of religious experiences biosemiotics may help to resolve some forms of Cartesian dualism that are still haunting philosophers and scientists biosemiotics of biochemistry biosemiotics proper deals with sign processes in nature in all dimensions (Emmeche) biosemiotics sections in semiotic conferences biosemiotics see the evolution of life and the evolution of semiotic systems as two aspects of the same process biosemiotics seems to propose for biology a sort of philosophical basis or background (Kalevi Kull) biosemiotics sees itself as general semiotics biosemiotics states that all processes going on in animate nature at whatever level, from the single cell to the ecosystem, should be analysed and conceptualised in terms of their character of being sign-processes (Jesper Hoffmeyer) biosemiotics study movements as signs biosemiotics study objects as signs biosemiotics study signs on molecular scales normally not perceived by an organism biosemiotics study smells as signs biosemiotics study sounds as signs biosemiotics study the signs in the physical and biologic realm in an attempt to integrate the findings of biology and semiotics biosystems are hierarchic systems and consequently, there is a hierarchy of Umwelts, hierarchy of adaptations, and hierarchy of meanings biosystems are hierarchic systems in the sense that they consist of several SRSs of different levels (Kalevi Kull) biotic evolution biparental recognition is an intrinsic mechanism which preserve species biparental reproduction blind alleys books on immunosemiotics books on semiotics that pay much attention to biosemiotics borrow a term botanist both information and correspondence are factual relationships that occur ubiquitously throughout the universe, and at least most of which are not representational Both the understanding of natural cognitive systems and the design of artificial cognitive systems will have to accommodate these conditions for emergence (Mark H. Bickhard) boundaries on our ability to know the final meaning of the genes boundary between the prebiotic and biotic evolution boundary conditions boundary conditions in biology embody at least the foundation for the special laws of the discipline, such as Mendelian genetics and Fisher’s population genetics boundary conditions in biology embody the special laws of the discipline (if any – if not, their closest analogue) boundary conditions in biology have considerable regularity boundary conditions in physics are typically distinguished from laws governing dynamical transitions Bowler 1983, Cannon 1957, Mayr 1972) branch of science branching of conditional interaction indications branching of indications Brauckmann breadth of an account break the information channel bridge between genes and organism bridge the gap between genetic information expression and function brief discussions Brier Brier has analyzed the problems of the integration of biosemiotics and cybernetics bring back a scientific tradition broad sense of notion of learning broaden the basis of a science broadening of the views brute fact Burks burn an object "But that dependence is asymmetric, it is not reciprocated, in the sense that cows evoking the cow representation would do so even if there never was and never would be a ""horse on a dark night"" evocation (Fodor) " But, as for Fodor's model, representing the current target is the original problem of representation that was to be accounted for (Mark H. Bickhard) by assumption C [internal state] indicates the success of M [behavior] "C [internal state] is recruited as a cause of M [behavior] because it ""indicates"" the success of M (Dretske) " C [internal state] is recruited as a cause of M [behavior] because of what it indicates about F [external conditions], the conditions on which the success of M depends (Dretske) C [internal state] is, so to speak, selected as a cause of M [behavior] because of what it indicates about F [external conditions] (Dretske) C [internal state] may be evoked in circumstances that do not include F [external conditions], contrary to the representational function of C [internal state] (Dretske) C. H. Waddington C.Nägeli calculate the information content Cambridge Club of theoretical biology can also be interpreted using more biological terms can also be interpreted using other terms can be can be derived from can be devastating can be sent over telegraph wires can be used to guide further interaction can differentiate environmental conditions can explain can get an idea how can have causal consequences in a system can infer from the facts can lead to explorations can make sense of can notice can occur can semiosis be modeled mathematically? can take place can the notion of anticipations of possible interactions be explicated in purely functional terms? candidates for a model of the nature of representation cannot account for the very possibility of error-guided behavior cannot account for the very possibility of error-guided learning cannot be defined in terms of cannot be underestimated cannot check their own representations cannot develop understanding any further cannot satisfy multiple criteria cannot work canonical example capability of detecting errors in your own representations capable of being causally efficacious capable of doing work capable of independent replication capable of providing a general definition of a concept capable of purposeful changes capable of replication only as part of a larger whole capacity for containing messages capacity for expressing messages capacity for replicating messages capacity of biological channels capacity of extracting messages’ signification capture a distinction capture Peirce's idea capture Peirce's ideas capture the basic normative issues of representation capture the importance of interpretation to signification Carnegie Institute carry genetic information reliably carry information carry information about relevant environmental conditions and changes carry information about the environmental conditions carry our experimental research carry small variations carry something over case of cellular semiosis cases in which semiotic aspects appear cases in which there are plausible emergent forms cases of emergence cases of functional error cases of representational error catalysis required for metabolism catalytic processes involved in epigenesis catalyzed assembly categorical perception categories as wholes with diffuse boundaries, although separated from the neighboring categories by hiatuses, are objects upon which natural languages are based, and for the description of which they are well suited (Kalevi Kull) causal based version of Dretske's model causal closure causal connection causal connection between two events causal consequence of configurations of basic particles causal consequence of organizations of basic particles causal consequence of processes of basic particles causal consequences causal consequences in a system via the glossing individual causal consequences of lower level constituents within that higher level organization causal correspondence is a form of informational correspondence causal difference causal efficacy of an organization causal isomorphisms causal model of how C [internal state] comes to be selected causal power causal power emerges in new process organizations causal power inhering in organization causal power of the organization causal powers causal powers of the fundamental particles causal relationship causally efficacious for organisms themselves with no observers around causally efficacious function causally efficacious organization causally efficacious properties of higher level organizations causally epiphenomenal causally epiphenomenal function causally epiphenomenal representation causally relevant issue cause of some behavior caused by the recognition taking place during biparental reproduction of one of its components cease to exist cell cohesion mechanism cell cohesion mechanism plays play obligate role in morphogenesis cell surface cell-cell recognition cell-cell recognition mechanism play obligate role in morphogenesis cell-cell recognition mechanisms cells are autopoietic structures cells are open to information (Collier) cells constitute the lowest level, semiotic atoms, in semiotic theory (Thure von Uexküll) central characteristics of living systems central idea central problems of naturalism central strategy certain features are more or less present certain kinds of far-from-equilibrium systems certain rise of interest certain uniparental organisms may form geo-species Ch. Morris chains of signs tend towards a definite but idealized end rather than progressing ad infinitum (Pierce) Chaitin challenges of non-epiphenomenal emergence challenges to the possibility of emergence chance events change in hereditary channels change of hereditary structure change the intensity of competition change toward becoming changeability of self-reproducing systems changed process changes in the state changes produced accidentally channel from A to B channels of genetic heredity channels of heredity channels of information channels of inheritance character of biological information character of the processes characteristic of eco-species characteristic of living beings characteristics of an object characterization of a transition Charles Bennett Charles Bennett’s notion of logical depth may provide a measure of organization Charles Darwin (1872) wrote a book on the evolution of emotions, which was an early work on ethology Charles Morris (1901-1979) check of the truth value of the indication chemical baths that depend on external reservoirs of reactants and pumps to introduce them into the bath are far from thermodynamic equilibrium systems (Nicolis, 1995; Nicolis & Prigogine, 1977, 1989) chemical evolution chemical language of blood chemical language of bone chemical language of muscle chemical language of nerves chemical networks chemical reactions chemical stability of DNA is final component of the transition from RNA to DNA chemical stability of DNA produced through the reduction of RNA chemistry as a study of semiotic chew an object choice of interaction means that there are more than one possibility for further interaction circle of foremost scientists circular glossing representations of an epistemic agent circularity of the representation of system goals conditions circumstances of utterance the sign cite a name claim textual support for somebody’s own view clarified implications class of environments class of favorable environments class of interactions class of models class of models for a set of sentences classes of counterfactuals classes of interactions classes of sign classic paradigm classical radical skeptical argument classification of sign types classification of sign types in Peirce’s early account of sign theory classification of sign types in Peirce’s final account of sign theory classification of sign types in Peirce’s interim account of sign theory classification of the sign in terms of the sign-vehicle and the object classifications imposed upon signs by elements of semiosis classificatory combinations classify a scientist classify signs in terms of their relation with their interpretant (Peirce) clear case of asymmetric dependency, clear notions clearest part of Peirce's final sign theories clearly biological processes clearly visible interpretation clever adaptation close into loops close into reciprocal indication relationships closeness of philosophies coarse phenotypic properties code duality is a formulation of biological information which is applicable to all levels of living systems (Kalevi Kull) code for chemical networks code for phenotypic properties code for proteins code for regulation code for social phenomena codes are collective rules that do not depend on individual features of their support structures (Barbieri (2001)) codes are rules of correspondence between two independent worlds (Barbieri (2001)) codes give meanings to informational structures (Barbieri (2001)) codified assembly coding processes involved in epigenesist coevolution is a biological problem coexistence of self-reproducing systems (SRSs) cogency of the genes representing cognition is a functional module cognition is not an autonomous subsystem cognition is taken to consist of various stages of the input and processing, and sometimes the output, of encodings cognition per se is seen as being organized around one or more storage banks for encodings cognitive content cognitive content depends on language which is a social activity cognitive contents cognitive ethology contributes to knowledge about biosemiosis because it deals with information processes at various levels cognitive issues cognitive processing Cognitive Science cognitive science contributes to knowledge about biosemiosis because it deals with information processes at various levels cohesion of an organization of process cohesion of far-from-equilibrium systems cohesion, in a very general sense, is the property of stability against perturbations (Mark H. Bickhard) cohesive level of a species cohesive level of an object cohesive level of an organism co-linear stars collapse of dominoes collection of articles edited by Sebeok and Umiker-Sebeok collection of examples of semiotic interpretation of biological phenomena collective article collective review of a book collective rules collierj@ukzn.ac.za combination of language structure with tolerance structure combination of properties combinations of logics combinatorial approaches used for information measurement combinatorial methods used for information measurement combinatorial methods used for information measurement are more appropriate for dealing with information in biological organism combinatorial methods used for information measurement work best on individuals combinatorial technologies used for information measurement combine genetic information come out in the wash of time come to be more efficient come to be more reliable commonalities between interactivism and Drescher's model commonalities between interactivism and Piaget's genetic epistemology communication begins with a decoder, not with the encoder, whether intentional or not and this insight is particularly crucial to the understanding of evolution as a part of semiosis (Kalevi Kull) communication in the immune system communication in the nervous system communication processes communicational interpretant communications theory can be used to analyze various biological channels in terms of their capacity, connectivity, order, and organization communicative aspects community of more than one species comparative anatomy as a study of semiotic compare different levels of biological organization compare interactivism with Drescher's model compare the interactive models of representation with other models of representation compare the use of information as a technology of measurement comparing the representational content with the current target comparison between interactivism and Drescher's model competing indications competition interaction may occur through a large number of different ways and we probably cannot reach a simultaneous measurement of all of them compile a sketch of semiotic paradigm in biology complementary base pairing complementary modes of conceptualization complementary modes of description complete conception of the objects of the sign complete discussion complete failure of mechanistic efforts to transplant biological theories into the science of language complete scientific knowledge complete understanding of an object completely passive systems completely sequential transitions complex artificial systems complex issues complex matter complex mixture of meanings in the theoretical spheres of biology complex organism with circulatory system is an instance of an including type that contains typical parts whose functions are to filter blood complex organisms complex organisms must have some functions served, such as filtering blood, if they are to persist at all, not just to be able to persist under certain conditions (Mark H. Bickhard) complex organisms with circulatory systems complex phenotypic properties complex relations complex representation complex selection processes complex self-organized living systems are constraining their their individual molecules action complex self-organized living systems are endowing their individual molecules with functional meanings in relation to the whole metabolism complex self-organized living systems are governed by final causality in the sense of their tendency to generate future interpretants of the present sign actions complex self-organized living systems are governed by final causality in the sense of their tendency to take habits complex self-organized living systems are governed by formal and final causality "complex self-organized living systems are governed by formal causality in the sense of the ""downward causation"" from a whole structure (such as the organism) to its individual molecules" complex systems complex webs of conditional interaction potentialities complexities of gene expression complexity in how genetic information is translated complexity of an account complexity of the embodiment of the information channel complicated system components in semiotic processes components of molecular processes comprehension of models without losing their identity with semiosis comprehension of the general character of the processes comprehensive analyses of the history of theoretical biology comprehensive theoretical system Computation, Cognition, and Consciousness computer science computers are human agents conceive the practical bearings of an effect concept of ecosemiotics by W. Nöth concept of emergence concept of information into biology concept of memes by R. Dawkins concept of recognition of species by H. Paterson (1993) conceptual clarity concern with whether heredity or environment (nature or nurture) cause certain traits conclude the description of a chapter concluding claims concluding claims of a section conclusion made in the epilogue conclusions of a valid argument concrete models of living systems condition of asymmetric dependency between the types of evocations conditional indications of possible system interactions conditional interaction potentialities conditionalization of indications of interaction potentialities creates the possibility of iterating such indications: if XYZ differentiation occurs, then QRS is possible, and if QRS occurs, then ABC will be possible conditions for emergence of function conditions for emergence of representation conditions within the organic environment conference participants conferences in biosemiotics configurations of fundamental particles conflict between levels of inclusion confront a new uncertainty confront an unpredicted uncertainty confuse the specimens of the population conjoin semiotics with biology connect to various forms of biological information connection between genetic information and function connection between the concept of operationality and the concept of information connection between the dynamic interpretant and the immediate object connection between the dynamic object and the process of inquiry in Peirce's later sign theory connection between the process of inquiry and sign chains connectionism posits representations constituted as distributions of activations across a space of (output) units connectionist approach to representation connectionist input processing connections between different aspects of a philosophy connections between immediate object and dynamic object connections between Peirce's later account and the end-directed process of inquiry connections between sign chains and inquiry connections between the semiotic process and the process of inquiry connections of dynamic interpretant to other elements of Peirce's semiotic connections of final interpretant to other elements of Peirce's semiotic connections that emerge from the notion of inquiry connectivity of biological channels Conrad Hal Waddington was the leader of “Towards a Theoretical Biology” symposia and volumes of original papers conscious mind consequences of actual relationships among variables consequences of biparental reproduction consequences of relationships consequences of self-reproduction consequences of the differing actions consider a counter-example consider a neurotransmitter docking on a receptor in a cell surface and evoking corresponding activities in the cell consider a poison molecule that mimics the neurotransmitter and also docks on that receptor consider an alternative model of representation consider epigenetic changes to be primary factors in evolutionary change consider only the indication of success of the behavior relationship consider something in a different respect consider the existential aspects of natural science consider the psychological aspects of natural science consider the sunflower, whose flower tends to face the sun very reliably consider things relevant to the higher standards required for explanation consider two conditions under which a representation is invoked, one purportedly correct and the other incorrect consider two views as indifferent considerable difference between the Baerian and Darwinian schools of thought in biology considerable difference between the holistic and reductionistic schools of thought in biology considerable difference in the successfulness of the attempts of holistic and reductionistic schools of thought to conjoin signs and life or semiotics and biology considerably long time consistent with contemporary quantum field theory constituents within that higher level organization constitute representation constitute something as a representation constitute the ontology of representation constraining process of the sign constraints on the objects within the level are connected to biological and cognitive form, enformation is the expressed information and it is distinguished from other forms of negentropy (Collier) construct a representational theory of the mind construct arguments construct networks of infomorphisms construct semantics out of semantic building blocks construct the anticipations of possible interactions construction of the theoretical system for theoretical biology constructive perception constructors are input/output systems construe representation construe representation in a backward in time looking manner construe representation in a future oriented manner construe the issue contact for the interactive model of representation is an aspect of epistemic relationship to the world contact with the environment is provided by the differentiations of that environment contain information produced by certain genes contain semantic information contemporary biosemiotic works contemporary challenges to naturalism contemporary scholars contemporary science claims that there are no particles, only processes (Mark H. Bickhard) contemporary science holds that particles are not all there is, there are also fields contemporary semiotic textbooks content for the interactive model of representation is an aspect of epistemic relationship to the world content of representation content of the sign context of cognition context of semiotics context of the sign context of the trends in biology context of the trends in semiotics context of the triadic structure of semiosis context of utterance of a sentence context of utterance of a sign contexts of the semiotic view in biology contextualize the normativity of function contibute to the solution of problems continuing supply of fuel continuing to swim down a sugar gradient is, in general, not appropriate continuous formulation of hypotheses continuous improvement of hypotheses continuous testing of hypotheses contradict the concept of emergence contradictory claims contrast different levels of biological organization contrastive discussions contribute to self maintenance contribute to the maintenance of far from equilibrium conditions contribute to the stability of a far-from equilibrium process contribution of the internal environment contributions in self-maintenant systems toward maintaining themselves in their far-from-equilibrium conditions constitute the emergence of normative function contributions to the creation of required conditions for the maintenance of the far-from-equilibrium processes contributions to the support of required conditions for the maintenance of the far-from-equilibrium processes control action of an agent control infrastructure of a system control might be regarded as requiring function, but function is not required for explaining gene expression control might be regarded as requiring intention, which adds to function some sort of meaningful purpose, but genes are not intentional control networks of complex phenotypic states composed of proteins and other substances control of a nuclear reactor control of the appropriate tissue kind by networks composed of proteins and other substances control the interaction of system with the environment controversial parts of Pierce’s final account of sign theory controversial significance convenient connection conventional correspondence conventional signs of which our language and cognition consist converge towards some intermediate state convert a population of single independent individuals into an integral whole corollary arguments corollary arguments against encodingism correct a deficit correct indication of appropriate interactions correct infrastructural properties correct logic correct metaphysics correct spatial properties correct system’s organization correct temporal properties correcting our logic, metaphysics, and epistemologies, however, does not guarantee acceptable models of emergence corrent epistemology correspond to relevant environmental conditions and changes correspondence does not exist correspondence is the basic category within which representations are differentiated (B. C. Smith, 1987) correspondence models of representation correspondence models of representation are past oriented correspondence models of representation have in principle difficulties handling modal representation correspondence models of representation must, at best, superimpose some additional criterion for error on the basic correspondence framework correspondence models of representation, including isomorphy models of representation, cannot account for representational error correspondence models of representation, including isomorphy models of representation, cannot account for the possibility of representational error (error of such correspondence) that is detectable by the system itself correspondence models of representation, simply do not inherently have the resources to account for representational error correspondence relationship correspondences between items in the system and conditions in the world corresponding approach corresponding extensions of a model cosmic evolution cosmological vision of evolution co-species is an eco-species which is preserved by recognition between specimens of the eco-species and a species, whereas the recognition is needed for the reproduction of the specimens of the eco-species could do with a could evaluate the terms count as information count for the transmission of information counter the impact of conditions counter the impact of processes counter-example counterexample to an assumption counterexamples counterexamples to Fodor’s model for managing representational error in correspondence models of representation counterfactuals "counterfactuals involving the various possible combinations of presence and absence of ""cow"" and ""horse"" evocations" counterpart of all living systems course of intellectual life cover all the varied uses of information concepts by biologists cover information with tolerance properties crank is a poison create a new situation for semiotics create an environment create an organization creation of regular discreteness in the morphological distribution of self-reproducing systems (SRSs) creation of regular discreteness in the spatial distribution of self-reproducing systems (SRSs) creation of regular discreteness in the temporal distribution of self-reproducing systems (SRSs) Crick’s central dogma criteria of behavioural success critical property of anticipations of possible interactions criticisms of Darwinism criticize something in the steps of an argument criticize the gene-centered approach of heredity critiques of notions of emergence cross-fertilization crucial fact crucial relationship crucial relationship in Dretske’s model of representation crush an object cultural heredity is based on written language, on spoken language and arts (G. Noutsos) cultural heredity is the way to integrate orgasmic life in planet life (G. Noutsos) cultural heredity is the way to make orgasmic life infinite (G. Noutsos) cultural sphere current internal conditions current point current position of the constellations current position of the earth current representational target current state of a system, in etiological approach of normative functions, is not adequate for the emergence of function (Mark H. Bickhard) current system goals currently dominant approach to understanding function currently known cursory discussion cursory nature of Peirce’s final account cut off a system from its environment Cyc model D. Dennett has made strong attempts to explain the intentional aspects of living systems (Kalevi Kull) D. Zahavi D.M.S.Watson D’Arsonval Danish Society for the Semiotics of Nature Darwin has made an important distinction between natural selection and sexual selection Darwin used the assumption of small variations Darwin’s contemporaries Darwin’s theory of selection Darwin’s views Darwinian biological theory Darwinian theory of natural selection obtained its mathematical basis, and the so-called modern synthesis took place, giving rise to the synthetic theory of evolution dashes of Morse code David Savan David Savan’s notion of immediate interpretant dawn of coding dawn of indefinite replication deal with biological knowledge deal with issues deal with the complications of gene expression decide to organize data decipher the genetic code deciphering of the DNA code has revealed our possession of a language much older than hieroglyphics, a language as old as life itself, a language that is the most living language of all’ (Beadle, Beadle 1966: 207) decisive criterion for the mystery of life decisive textual evidence on a scientific matter declare that semiotics could be the basis for biology decline in general interest in theoretical biology decoupling of genotype and phenotype dedicated metabolism deductive reasoning deep analogy deep fundament for future biology deep questions deepening of the views deeply buried implicit assumption default condition of a passive system default condition of a system defense of metaphysical emergence definable in terms of current state of the system define autopoiesis in terms of operational closure (Maturana and Varela) define codes define something in terms of itself define the indications of appropriate interactions in an environment in terms of current state define what to call the living process defined terms defining clauses definite descriptions definite end definition for the axioms of geometry definition of a self-reproducing system definitional understanding deflation of emergence degree of discreteness degree of modularity into genotypic changes degree of modularity into resulting phenotypic changes delimit a time period delimit each other's range of variability delimit the field of biosemiotics delimit what to call the living process delimited by reciprocal recognition needed for the reproduction of self-reproducing systems (SRSs) of both delimited by the recognition of certain species delimited by the width of closed valley in the adaptive landscape of abiotic conditions delineate two camps delome - symbolic – legisign type of sign demarcation of the species demonstrate that no non-functional notions are necessary in a model demonstrate the adequacy of pointers and subroutines demonstrate the adequacy of the interactive model for all forms of purported representation demonstrated adequacy of interactive representation denial of intuitions is a key assumption of Cartesian philosophical method (Peirce) density of every separate type of self-reproducing system (SRS) Department of Psychology depend on conditions within the organic environment dependence on the proper learning history dependence on unnaturalizable observers (Mark H. Bickhard) deploy different processes depending on differences in the environmental circumstances deploy processes depths of downward causation derive from false epistemologies derive from illegitimate logical restrictions derive from incorrect metaphysics derive information from a sign by deductive reasoning derive the pragmatist influences from Jean Piaget describable in the language of physics describe biological species using natural languages describe the dynamic interpretant describe the evolution of communication describe the evolution of the DNA code describe the final interpretant describe the formation of self-organized structures in prebiotic evolution describe the heredity of self-organized structures in prebiotic evolution describe the immediate interpretant describe the replication of self-organized structures in prebiotic evolution descriptive adequacy deserve attention deserve to be examined deserves special analysis design beings with minds design goals in artificial intelligence design of artificial cognitive systems designated outcome designed agents desire a more complex design despite appearances despite numerous recent criticisms despite the explanations given to a notion in a scientific field despite the explanations given to goal-directedness in cybernetics despite the non-genetic dependency despite the various signs destabilizing force destabilizing force in a system destinate interpretant detect errors detect that error detection of error in a system detection of error in an organism determinate understanding of what somebody means determine its own representational content determine the internal environments determine the matching between representational evocations determine what happens in the world determine what its own representations are supposed to represent determine what the representations are supposed to represent determine what the system does develop a logical framework develop a metaphysical framework develop a scientific view develop a series of dynamic interpretants develop complex functions of motivation develop complex functions of representation develop conditions develop critiques of notions of emergence develop processes develop sciences of recognition develop the autogenetic view develop the problem of biological basis of cognition develop the semiotic understanding of biological phenomena develop understanding further develope ideas about semiotic develope ideas about signs develope ideas on signs develope something into an exact system of assumptions and consequences developed an approach in an extensive way developing a thoroughgoing theory of signs development is an active constructive process (Bickhard, 1992) development of biocybernetics development of biophysics development of mathematical biology development of mental features development of molecular biology development of protocells development of semiotic consciousness development of semiotic paradigm in biology development of the recognition concept of species development of the views of a scientist development of Uexküll’s views developmental change developmental channels developmental logic of other branches of sciences developmental systems theory developments in symbolic logic made by Peirce and Oscar Mitchell "devote to biosemiotics an issue of a periodical ""Vita aeterna"" " diagnose errors diagnose programmatic errors dialogue between Baerian and Darwinian thinking in biology dicent – indexical – legisign type of sign dicent – indexical – sinsign type of sign dicent - symbolic – legisign type of sign difference between human perception and real world difference between particles and processes difference in behaviour between the species difference in structure between the species differences between codified assembly and catalyzed assembly differences between genetic epistemology and evolutionary epistemology differences between interactive models and standard models differences between interactivism and Drescher's model differences between interactivism and Piaget's genetic epistemology differences between organisms differences in the environmental circumstances differences of interactivism with encoding models different effect different objects different things different trichotomies different types differential reproduction differential reproduction in genetically diverse populations differential reproduction is the main mechanism of adaptation differentiate an environment differentiate emergence into various strengths differentiate types of environments differentiation and heterochrony differentiation and representation of system goals conditions without invoking a circularity in the model of representation (Mark H. Bickhard) differentiation in general is generated by the internal outcomes of previous interactions differentiation of engagement environments differentiations in general may involve full interactions, but a simple version would be a differentiation process that had no outputs, a passive differentiation differentiations per se have no content (Mark H. Bickhard) differing depths of downward causation differing environments will yield differing internal courses of the interaction and differing internal outcomes of the interaction differing forms of non-linearity of interactions differing functional aspects differing functional aspects of one underlying system organization differing processes in a recursive self-maintenant system differing processes that contribute to self-maintenance diffuse boundaries digression on motivation per se dinstictive acccounts direct check of the truth value of the indication direct conflict direct conflict between information semantics approaches and the interactive model of representations direct consequence of information theory direct consequences of self-reproduction direct intuitive meaning direct logical consequences direct triggering kind of indication directing of energy discard bad hypotheses about the environment of a system discover new biological laws discover new biological mechanisms discoveries in immunology discreteness of genes discreteness of genes in DNA code greatly enhances the efficiency of the code in the sense of using the same parts in different combinations to express different information discreteness of genes in DNA code greatly enhances the possibility of both collectivity and independence of support structures discuss issues discuss the internal operations of the system discussa a model discussion of emergence discussion of the substantive use of information in biology disease may be seen as the result of erroneous communication among our body parts (Jesper Hoffmeyer) disentangle the notions disjunction problem is just one version of the general problem of accounting for representational error dismiss the importance of icons and indices as signs dismiss the relevance of icons and indices as signs disparate biologists dissolve an object in acid distinct branch in semiotics distinct causal consequences distinct decoupling of information transmission and metabolism distinct modules distinct processes distinct trichotomies distinct types of eco-species distinction between heuristic and substantive uses of information Sarkar (2000) distinction between instrumental and substantive uses of information in biological studies distinction between natural selection and sexual selection distinctive characteristic of semiotic biology distinctive feature distinguish between chemical evolution and biological evolution distinguish between descriptive and explanatory adequacy (Chomsky 1959) distinguish between the application of two scientific approaches distinguish life from anything else in the physical world distinguish the specimens of a population from the specimens of other populations distinguish the use of information technology in studying the properties of a system from the substantive attribution of information to a system distribute activations across a space of (output) units distributed biological information channels distributed network of information channels distributed systems distrust joint designs diversification of behaviour diversification of structure diversification of theoretical approaches in biology dividing the Interpretant dividing The Object division of interpretants division of interpretants due to the parallels between semiotic and inquiry division of labor DNA and protein have grammar and syntax, and we have already come upon typographical errors, double meanings, synonyms, and other subtleties (Kalevi Kull) DNA code DNA contains information about the phenotype of the organism for the organism itself, rather than from merely external view of some anthropomorphizing observer (Collier) DNA does not contain the key to its own interpretation (Jesper Hoffmeyer) DNA has two major implications for inheritance and variability, required for evolution DNA is probably the biological entity most closely associated with information DNA is the predominant if not the only focus of biological information transmission DNA molecule is in a way hermetic DNA selection is a morphogenic process DNA selection is an informationgenic process DNAese DNA-RNA-protein interactions DNA-RNA-protein interactions are often considered as representing a good example of biological text or language do not include directly into the definition do specialized systems like the immune system present intentionality? Does a bacterium test and generate hypotheses about its environment? domains of biosemiotics dominant alternative account of normative function dominant approach to model function dominant approach to understanding function doom an approache dopamine is a neurotransmitter dopamine nomological correspondences dots of Morse code double meanings double stranded RNA doubt-prone beliefs doubt-proof beliefs downward causation drawbacks of a contemporary approach for adaptation Drescher has recognized the importance of pragmatic error for learning, but has not recognized the emergence of representational error, thus representational content, out of pragmatic error (Bickhard and Terveen) Drescher’s work Drescher’s work in artificial intelligence Drescher's model Drescher's model carry over problematics about encodingism Drescher's model construes representation -- that which is learned -- in terms of correspondences between items in the system and conditions in the world (cf. Dretske, 1988) Drescher's model of perception is action based, constructive, and modal Drescher's model of representation is a momentous advance over standard approaches in the literature of artificial intelligence and cognitive science Drescher's model of representation is essentially that of Piaget Drescher's model recognizes the necessity of action feedback for learning -- in particular, pragmatic error feedback of when an action does not work as anticipated Drescher's model recognizes the necessity of action feedback for the construction of representation Dretske has the differentiating state representing such a set of properties, in virtue of its having been recruited (Mark H. Bickhard) "Dretske intends the ""because"" in his definition of the model, in an explanatory sense (Mark H. Bickhard) " Dretske, however, is not attempting a causal model (Mark H. Bickhard) Dretske’s approach to representation Dretske’s model as an etiological model it is epiphenomenal: representation is not definable in terms of current state (Mark H. Bickhard) Dretske’s model fails to be naturalistic (Mark H. Bickhard) Dretske’s model is a kind of etiological model of representation Dretske’s model of representation is focused on a cause of behavior Dretske's etiological model Dretske's etiological model offer an account of the possibility of system detectable error (Mark H. Bickhard) Dretske's model does not accept that an interaction might create an environmental condition (F) Dretske's model fails to be naturalistic because it is a model of representational ascription-in-explanation, not of the metaphysics of representation per se (Mark H. Bickhard) Dretske's model fails to be naturalistic because it is causally epiphenomenal in its dependence on the proper learning history, and, therefore, its inability to be defined in terms of current state Dretske's model for representation is a spectator, backward-in-time looking model Dretske's model is state and action based Dretske's model of representation drop an object due to someone due to the works of Uexküll Durban during the same sexual recognition dustbin of history dynamic interpretant dynamic interpretants are the effect actually produced on the mind (Pierce) dynamic of the ecosystem dynamic presupposition can be of particular conditions obtaining at particular places and times dynamic presupposition can be of particular phenomena occurring at particular places and times "dynamic presupposition gives rise to a typification that grounds ""having a function” " dynamic presupposition is dependent on the presupposing processes being metaphysically capable of success and failure (Mark H. Bickhard) dynamic presupposition is itself already a normative property dynamic presuppositions dynamic presuppositions can be false dynamic presuppositions made in indications of interactive potentiality are implicit in the indications themselves dynamic presuppositions made in indications of interactive potentiality are not explicitly represented dynamic processes dynamic systems approaches dynamic trichotomy dynamical conditions dynamical decoupling of energy and information in biological systems has led to the production of more complex informational regularities of the sort described by Brooks and Wiley (1988),as minor transitions dynamical decoupling of energy and information in biological systems has led to the production of more complex informational regularities of the sort described by Maynard Smith and Szathmáry as major transitions (Collier) dynamical kinds of classes dynamical models are process models dynamical separation dynamics Dynamics and Function dysfunctional parts of a complex organism dysfunctional parts of a complex organism are those that have a function but the do not do so dysfunctional parts of a system dysfunctional parts of an including type E. Bauer E. Bleuler E. C. Zeeman E. Cassirer) E. Cope E. Hering (1912) E. O. Wilson E. P. Odum E. Rignano E. Szathmary E.Dacqué’s (1929) title ‘Leben als Symbol’ E.Mayr E.Mayr’s analysis of biological teleology each cell is capable of interpreting a limited range of molecular signs each difference in behaviour or structure between the species may play an important role in changing the intensity of competition each element of signs and signification can participate only in permissible combinations between elements each element of signs and signification has three qualifying classes each of the genetic changes is produced accidentally and is then retained by relative fitness advantages each of the immediate, dynamic and final interpretants may be further sub-divided into emotional, energetic and logical (Short 1981, 1996, and 2004) each sign is then classifiable as some combination of each of its three elements, that is, as either one of the three types of sign-vehicle, plus one of the three types of object, plus one of the three types of interpretant Each way in which information is thought to play a substantive role in the sciences inherits the logical and ontological commitments of the containing views but adds further restrictions early anti-Darwinian theories early development sea urchins early examples of icons include the portraits and noted similarities between the letters p and b (Peirce) early examples of indices include the weathercock, and the relationship between the murderer and his victim (Peirce) "early examples of symbols include the words “homme"" and ""man"" sharing a reference (Peirce)" early pioneers of biosemiotics early sensory systems early transitions of evolution ecological communities ecological networks ecology is a branch of biology in which holistic views have had a strong influence, together with reductionist approaches economics as a study of semiotic ecophysiologist eco-species group of genetically close self-reproducing systems (SRSs) preserved by broken or non-continuous environment are called ecto-species as far as the reason for preserving the range of variability is external Edgar Dacqué (1878–1945) effect of Peirce's greater appreciation of the parallels between inquiry and his sign theory effect on the prestige of evolutionary biology effective interpretant effective multiplier in effects of heterochrony effects with practical bearings efficiency of genes replication efficiency of replication efficiency of reproduction efficient causation efficient components efficient recognition efforts to fuse linguistic criteria in biology efforts to fuse racial criteria in biology efforts to transplant biological theories into the science of language eighth epigenetic step of organ assembly into organism elaborate the details of extensions of a model elaboration of a simple model electronics science element of signs and signification that focus on the relation between signs, objects and interpretants element of the grounding level of encodings elementary self-reproducing system (SRS) elements of signification are the sign-vehicle, the object, and the interpretant elements of signs eliminate definitions eliminate terms by substituting the defining clauses elude a naturalistic account emerge naturally in agents emerge problems Emergence emergence is alive and well, and of extreme importance in understanding our world emergence is constituted as new causally efficacious properties of higher level organizations emergence is demarcated by differing forms of non-linearity of interactions (Bickhard & Campbell, forthcoming; Campbell, 1974b, 1990; see also Beckmann, Flohr, Kim, 1992; Collier, 1995; O'Conner, 1994) emergence is differentiated into various strengths by differing depths of downward causation (Bickhard & Campbell, forthcoming; Campbell, 1974b, 1990; see also Beckmann, Flohr, Kim, 1992; Collier, 1995; O'Conner, 1994) emergence of a conflict emergence of a direct conflict emergence of causally efficacious function emergence of function and representation is a natural phenomena, however, in multiple senses of the word, if a process metaphysics is appropriate emergence of function and representation is not possible if the world is composed only of particles emergence of function in a system emergence of functional types emergence of normative function emergence of representation emergence of representation by recursive self-maintenance emergence of representation by recursive self-maintenance satisfies multiple criteria that standard approaches to representation such as symbolic or connectionist, or those of Fodor, Dretske, or Millikan – cannot satisfy emergence of representational content out of pragmatic error emergence of representational error emergence of representational truth value emergence of serving a function emergent causal power emergent causal power is non-epiphenomenal emergence emergent causal powers emergent content for the relevant system is in some relevant sense possessed by the organism, not by an observer of that organism emergent content for the relevant system that might permit the organism to be in error, and, perhaps, to detect that error (Mark H. Bickhard) emergent ontology of function emergent properties of representation emergent property emotional interpretant emphasize the basic assumption empirical science empirically definable modalities empiricist assumption empiricist epistemological constraints are illegitimate empiricist epistemologies empiricist presuppositions encoding correspondences in the representational elements are designed (Newell, 1980) encoding correspondences in the representational elements are innate (Fodor, 1981) encoding correspondences in the representational elements are transduced (Fodor & Pylyshyn, 1981) encoding correspondences in the representational elements are transduced trained into a net (Churchland, 1989) encoding models of representation encoding models of the nature of representation are wrong (Bickhard) encoding orientations encoding representations are consistent with models of completely passive systems encoding representations represent in virtue of some correspondence between them and that which they represent encodingism and its associated modularizations of action and interaction, representation and motivation dominate contemporary artificial intelligence and cognitive science encodingism assumption per se has yielded an incoherence, it assumes a grounding level of encoding elements, which cannot exist encodingism claims that the fundamental nature of representation is encodings (Palmer, 1978) encodingism requires a grounding level of encodings encodings are not dependent on action encodings borrow the representational content from what they stand-in for encodings cannot be encodings without explicit content encodings cannot be the basic nature of representation (Bickhard) encodings clearly do exist encodings do not require any agent in order to exist encounter an incoherence encounter the sorts of problems encyclopedia article 'Biosemiotics' encyclopedia entry Encyclopedia of Semiotics, P.Bouissac (ed.), New York: Oxford University Press end directed process end- directedness of a process end-directedness of the semiotic process endless mazes of blind alleys endocytobiology and cell research endocytobiosis is seemingly leading to the formation of federative species endosemiotics has only recently been subject to more detailed study (Uexküll 1986, Hoffmeyer 1997) endosemiotics is concerned with sign processes that take place in the interior of organisms endo-species is the true species or biological species endosymbiosis is a biological problem energetic aspects of infrastructure in recursive self-maintenance processes are concerned with the accomplishment of the processes to which the system can be switched (Mark H. Bickhard) energetic aspects of infrastructure in recursive self-maintenance processes are concerned with the accomplishment of the switching energetic interpretant energetic transformations energy degenerate states energy directing aspect of infrastructure energy directing aspect of infrastructure suggests a kind of autonomy that is in between self maintenance and recursive self maintenance (Mark H. Bickhard) energy is also stored and transmitted in organisms energy well process organizations, such as an atom or a rock, exhibit a fundamental form of cohesion (Mark H. Bickhard) energy well process stability energy well stabilities energy well stability is exhibited when some organization of process requires energy to change its organization and the ambient environment does not impinge that level of energy into or onto the process (Mark H. Bickhard) enformation asymmetry in the control of higher and lower level is biologically important enformation or expressed information at higher levels is able to control information at its own and higher levels more completely (Collier 1990b, 2003) enformation or expressed information at higher levels is able to control information at lower levels only to a certain degree and sometimes this is called downward causation (Collier 1990b, 2003) enformation or the expressed information is relative to a certain level in a hierarchy (Collier 2003) engage a subroutine engage in subordinate interactions engage in the motivational selections of actions to be performed engage interactions engineering usage enhance the role for substantive information enter data into banks for encodings of cognition entities that were capable of independent replication before the transition of evolution can replicate only as part of a larger whole after the transition entropy is the disorder of the lower level environmental agent environmental circumstances environmental conditions on which the success of behavior depends environmental conditions that serve to indicate the appropriateness of particular further interactions for maintaining relevant far-from-equilibrium conditions environmental conditions that support the success of the behavior environmental differentiations environmental differentiations in a recursive self-maintenant system environmental differentiations will be of environments in which one process is appropriate versus those in which some other is appropriate (Mark H. Bickhard) environmental features environmental properties that support the corresponding internal differentiations environmental variation environments are not always so simple enzyme action enzyme actions contain a message like ‘carry out chemical reaction X here’ enzymes are functional enzymes not merely chemicals enzymes should not be understood informationally (Maynard Smith (2000a)) epigenesis provides the pragmatics in biological representation (Collier) epigenetic changes epigenetic steps of the second part of the bridge between genes and organism correspond to common phenotypic levels epiphenomena belonging to a population as a system epiphenomenal model of function epiphenomenality of function epiphenomenality of function in etiological approach of representation epistemic access epistemic agent epistemic agent is the agent that could be glossed as making use of representation epistemic agent is the agent that itself makes use of representation epistemologic problems of biology epistolary equality of cognitive and adaptive processes equally successful equilibrium and far from equilibrium conditions have very different consequences, and there is an inherent asymmetric tendency towards equilibrium equilibrium conditions equilibrium processes Ernst Cassirer (1874–1945) Ernst Haeckel Ernst Mayr erroneous interpretation error guided processes error information, in indicated interaction final states or outcomes, can be used to guide further interaction, perhaps in a TOTE organization, or not, or to guide learning processes (Mark H. Bickhard) error of representation error of representation is directly system detectable (Mark H. Bickhard) error-guided behavior error-guided learning essence of the matter-symbol problem essence of the measurement or recording problem essential condition essential way establish a link establish a similar activity establishment of Biometrika journal establishment of semiotic biology esteem of evolutionary biology within biology estimate the information content Estonian Academy of Sciences Estonian Spring Schools in Theoretical Biology ethics as a study of semiotic ethological congresses ethological revies ethology is a branch in biology ethology was established as a scientific branch and mainly developed in the XX century etiological account of normative functions etiological approach has a ready answer to the question about representational error etiological approach is not a paradigm instance of informational semantics etiological approach of normative functions can make sense of, can explain, why a particular kind of (sub)system exists i.e. kidneys "etiological approach of normative functions can perhaps explicate the notion of ""being designed"" for some function (Allen & Beckoff, 1995)" etiological approach of normative functions cannot naturalistically explicate the emergent ontology of function itself (Mark H. Bickhard) etiological approach of normative functions fails as a naturalistic model of function because it renders the current state of a system inadequate for the emergence of function (Mark H. Bickhard) etiological approach of normative functions fails to provide a naturalistic account of function, unless function truly is just a matter of gloss, with no causal consequences in a system itself - excepts perhaps via the glossing individual etiological approach of normative functions gives us a model of function that is causally epiphenomenal (Bickhard, 1993, 1998) (Mark H. Bickhard) etiological approach of representation is not a naturalistic model of representation etiological approach of representation makes system detectable representational error impossible, but it clearly is in fact possible, so they are refuted (Mark H. Bickhard) etiological approach to model function etiological approaches etiological epiphenomenalism etiological models of function etiological models of function are epiphenomenal eukaryotic cell and bacterium is a pair of co-evolutionary species eukaryotic cell and virus is a pair of co-evolutionary species eukaryotic’s cell endosymbionts are the bacteria and viruses evaluate the aptness evaluate the implications evaluate the terms applied in neovitalism evaluate whether information in some substantive role has a place in biology Evelyn Fox Keller even further "even if an organism had access to its own representational contents, the detection of error would require comparing that content with the current target - the ""cow"" representation with the actual horse - to determine that they did not match" events that influenced theoretical biology events with a long-lasting effect on biology every causal connection between two events, for example, creates a correspondence from the second to the first (and vice versa) and creates an informational relationship between the two every interpretant is itself a further sign of the signified object (Peirce) everything is quantized field processes (Mark H. Bickhard) evocation of a representation "evocation of a representation that represents ""cows OR horses on dark nights"" " evocation of internal states evolution by selection is not anticipative evolution of DNA translation evolution of life is based on code-duality principle (Hoffmeyer and Emmeche 1991) evolution of semiotic systems evolutionarily significant evolutionary epistemology evolutionary ground for representation evolutionary history of the functional representations of a system evolutionary perspectives evolutionary perspectives into a scientific field evolutionary predecessors evolutionary time evolutionists evolve gradually evolve in parallel evolve through evolutionary processes exact system of assumptions exact system of consequences exactly in the way examine a model examine an approach examine Peirce’s accounts examine the aspects of the nature of representation examine the dynamic interpretant examine the final interpretant examine the immediate interpretant "example of a delome - symbolic – legisign type of sign is ""An argument""" "example of a dicent – indexical – legisign type of sign is ""A street cry""" "example of a dicent – indexical – sinsign type of sign is ""A Weather Cock""" "example of a dicent - symbolic – legisign type of sign is ""Ordinary proposition""" "example of a rhematic – iconic – legisign type of sign is ""A diagram [type]""" "example of a rhematic – iconic – qualisign type of sign is ""A feeling of red""" "example of a rhematic – iconic – sinsign type of sign is ""An Individual Diagram""" "example of a rhematic – indexical – legisign type of sign is ""A demonstrative pronoun""" "example of a rhematic – indexical – sinsign type of sign is ""A spontaneous cry""" "example of a rhematic - symbolic – legisign type of sign is ""A common noun""" Example of a system with infrastructure that contributed to self maintenance via the directing of energy, the accomplishment of relevant work, but with no alternatives, no relevant informational aspects example of biological language example of biological text example of dopamine and crank for assymetrical dependence example of iterated indications of possible system interactions examples of causal correspondence of the information semantics approach examples of causally efficacious function examples of conventional correspondence examples of co-species "examples of dicents is to think of them as saturated predicates, or propositions, like ""Fido is a dog"", ""Larry is happy"", ""Fido loves Larry"", ""Larry gives food to Fido"", and so on" examples of dynamic interpretant examples of etiological approaches of normative function examples of failure of the causal closure of the physical world examples of far-from-equilibrium processes dependent for their continued existence on continued external sources of support examples of far-from-equilibrium processes that tend to maintain themselves examples of federative species examples of Fodor’s way of managing representational error in correspondence models of representation examples of general reciprocal mechanisms examples of genuine emergence examples of icons as signs examples of immediate interpretant examples of infrastructure in recursive self maintenance examples of intervening interactions examples of lawful correspondence "examples of rhemes is to think of them as unsaturated predicates like, ""— is a dog"", ""— is happy"", ""— loves —"" or ""— gives — to —""" examples of semiotic interpretation of biological phenomena examples of signs whose sign-vehicle relies upon a quality examples of signs whose sign-vehicle uses conventions surrounding their use, habits or laws examples of signs whose sign-vehicle uses existential facts examples of strictly informational correspondence examples of switching mechanisms in recursive self maintenance examples of the final interpretant examples of types execute interactions exemplar exhaustive typology of signs exist after a period exist before a period existence of intermediate forms existence of needs existence of regular hiatuses existence of substantive information within the system being studied existential aspects of natural science existential fact existing definitions of a self-reproducing system (SRS) on the basis of the Petri nets existing definitions of a self-reproducing system (SRS) on the basis of the Petri nets or differential equations formalism do not include directly the assumption of variability into the definition (Kalevi Kull) existing notion of adaptation in biology exosemiotics deals with sign processes between organisms exosemiotics is interested in inter-specific communication (Bouissac 1993) exosemiotics is the most well studied area in biosemiotics exosemiotics is the object for research in several disciplines such as ethology, sociobiology and behavioural ecology exosemiotics may be concerned with alarm calls in birds exosemiotics may be concerned with Japanese greetings rituals exosemiotics may be concerned with pheromone emission by insects exosemiotics may be concerned with the dances of cranes expansion of semiotic freedom is the increase in richness or depth of meaning that can be communicated (Hoffmeyer 1996: 61). expend energy experience an absolute low esteem experience continuous progress experiment with terminology experimental biology experimental measurement of competition in field conditions experimental research into animal umwelts experimental work in an area explain even across non-reducible levels explain information theoretic methods to biology explain the intentional aspects of living systems explain the use of the idea of information by biologists explanation of animal behaviour explanation of coexistence of species inhabiting similar niche explanation of the scarcity of semiotic biology in this century explanations given to goal-directedness in cybernetics explanatory adequacy explanatory based version of Dretske's model explanatory role of information explicate a notion explicate the conditions under which it would be appropriate to talk about something explicit assumption explicit content of the sign explicit definitional constraints are illegitimate explicit elements in the sign explicit form of content explicit interpretant explicit level explicitly use exponent of semiotic means express a similar idea with someone express a truth in a conditional proposition express more clearly the connections between different aspects of a philosophy extend far outside a profession extend the model of Physical Symbol System Hypothesis to representation -- in particular, to representation of external entities extended example extensions of a model extensive account of signification extensive commentaries external case external conditions external description of autopoietic systems external forms of representation external forms of representation require interpretation and understanding external interpretants process the cultural heredity of an organism i.e. writings, creations, speech, movements and actions (G. Noutsos) external perspective external reason extremely complex sphere of biological theories extremely difficult extremely fertile ground face challenges face with a dilemma factually inadequate position fail as a sign of the object fail to contribute to the maintenance of far from equilibrium conditions fail to provide a naturalistic account of normative function failure of the causal closure of the physical world fairly direct intuitive meaning false attributions are asymmetrically dependent on correct attributions (Fodor) false epistemologies false evocations are dependent on true evocations, but asymmetrically so (Fodor) false evocations are in some sense parasitic on true evocations (Fodor) false indication of appropriate interactions false metaphysics false predication false underlying presupposition concerning the nature of representation familiar representations familiarity with a sign far from equilibrium processes manifest an inherent asymmetry far from equilibrium thermodynamics offers a process, and pragmatic, framework for alternatives: self-maintenance yields function, and recursive self-maintenance yields representation far from thermodynamic equilibrium systems far from thermodynamic equilibrium systems are dependent on external processes to maintain their far from equilibrium conditions Far-